 |
|
BASIC KNOWLEDGE OF AQUARIUM KEEPING |
|
|
|
| |
| |
| |
| |
|
Home Aquarium Filtration Fish tank Filters
|
Written by Ray Budiardja
|
Fish tank Filters
Why we need Fish tank Filters ?
In perfect ecosystems -s.a rivers- where fishes, water turtles, water plants & other aquatic organisms live and grow healthy, continuous water flow which brings new water will keep the perfect and stable equilibrium of water quality.
In a closed environment like aquarium, small changes have great effects. A fish that dies in the river does not change the river conditions. But in your aquarium, it can deteriorate water conditions quickly. The decomposition of organic matter produces chemical by-products that toxic to life. Smaller changes, like fish waste, uneaten fish food, even pollution from the air create shifts in pH and other important parameters over time.
That's why, you should monitor and correct small, everyday changes in your aquarium water to avoid greater changes further along. The most important tools that exist for this purpose are fish tank filters.
Fish tank filter corrects certain unwanted changes to your water conditions. These changes fall into three categories:
- toxins in your aquarium water from the decomposition of organic matter.
- dirty or cloudy water caused by physical debris - dirt, excess food, waste, etc.
- other chemicals in your water caused by pollution from additives, medicines, tap water, the air around your tank, etc.
The first two conditions are completely unavoidable in an aquarium, but the last condition might only arise at times. Fish tank filter is designed to overcome above conditions.
Read more about fish tank filters functions, types and how to choose them on the next tabs.
Biological Filtration
Biological filtration means that we provide media for bacteria to live and colonize. Bacteria takes very important part in Aquarium Cycle.
Actually, biological filtration already taken place in your aquarium substrates s.a sand, gravel, stone, in driftwoods and even in water plants. But, it's not enough for processing ammonia and nitrite that formed in aquarium. So, we need bigger place for bacteria habitat, in filter media.
Biological filter media is designed for maximum surface area. You'll find the same types of media at work in most fish filters. The differences are in the amount of space that fish filters provided for biological media and how the oxygen provided into the filtration system. If you have a large tank or a heavy bio-load, you will need a bigger space for bacteria to colonize.
The oxygen provided into the fish filter is very important. The bacteria you need for nitrification and nitration process are aerobic : they need plenty of oxygen to live and grow. Increasing waste makes these bacteria quickly deplete the dissolved oxygen in your aquarium water, endangering your aquatic friends. Good aeration with simple airstone or sponge filters is very important to keep the oxygen at acceptable level. Some fish filters which keep bacteria separate from your tank - s.a canister filters or fluidized bed filters - will have problem to move enough oxygen when a power loss stops filter flow.
So, what you need is the right amount of surface area for effective biological filtration, which is vital to the health and life of your organisms. The right amount varies, it depends on biological needs of your tank, and will heavily influence your choice of fish filter.
Mechanical Filtration
Mechanical filter strains particles from your aquarium water, providing clean and clear water. It's very important to have good mechanical filtration as seperated fish filter or as prefilter before biological filtration. It's main job is to avoid biological filter from clogging by providing prefiltered/ cleaner water. You should check and clean your mechanical filter regularly - especially for 3 stages fish tank filters - to keep good water flow that providing oxygen to biological media.
Mechanical filtration is really quite simple, it's just a filter cartridges that strains particles from the water. Most fish filters perform this function well, although some are better than others.
Chemical Filtration
Chemical filtration is needed to remove chemicals from your aquarium water. How chemicals get in your fish tank ?
Chemicals like phosphate and silicate, usually come from tap water, fish food, or other additives. Other chemicals enter your tank most commonly through fish medications .
All of the chemicals can be removed by using chemical filtration - usually the third stage of 3 stages filtration system. Remember that phosphate and silicate cause algae blooms (especially brown algae/ diatom bloom)!. Chemicals that come from your tap water can be removed by using reverse-osmosis purifiers or water deionizers before entering your fish tank.
Medications should be done in a quarantine tank for the sick fishes only. But if the main tank should be treated due to spreading infections, a chemical filter will remove the medicine afterwards.
Most types of fish tank filters include chemical filtration as part of their system. Some provide optional add-ons, since this type of aquarium filtration has limited /temporary usage.
External Power filter or HOB (Hang on Back). This fish tank filter hang on to the back or side of your fish tank and quite easy to use, that's why this fish filter is a popular filter among hobbyists. But its limited space for filter media make this fish tank filters are only suitable for small aquariums only - up to 50 gallons.
But, nowadays advanced aquarium technology makes HOB power filters more powerful s.a :
• increasing the filter cartridge capacity & additional chemical filtration capability.
• using BIO-Wheel as a wet/dry biological filtration.
The patented BIO-Wheel is a good biological filter, as it serves as the ideal culture site for the growth and proliferation of beneficial bacteria responsible for nitrification in aquatic environments.
• operating two separate water pumps.
The pumps send water in two different directions through the filter to provide balanced filtration :
- The Flow Pump routes water through the filter cartridge which provides mechanical and chemical filtration (pre-filter).
- The BIO-Pump pressurizes and sends a stream of pre-filtered water through the spray bar to power-drive the BIO-Wheel.
All of that will increase the flow and filtration efficiencies, some brands have tank-size capacity over 100 gallon!
If the chamber /media for biological filtration is still not enough (not providing enough surface area for an adequate bacterial bed) for your tank's need, turn your HOB into 100% mechanical filter (if possible) to support seperated 100% biological filtration.
Canister filter is external pressurized fish filter for larger aquariums, the size varies up to 400 gallons, even more. This fish tank filters operate by using hoses to supply water to the filter system and pump the clean water back to your tank. You should pay attention on distance between your fish tank and the canister filter that set up underneath your tank. Distance affects the ability of the fish filter to pump water up. Read the manuals carefully to know the maximum distance allowed.
Almost all aquarium canister filters provide 3-stage filtration (mechanical, biological and chemical). Although all brands claim to be the best at all 3 stages, I recommend to use this fish tank filter as 100% biological filtration. Why ?
In time, accumulate waste in mechanical filter - as prefilter - will slow down the water flow that brings oxygen to biological filter. Yes, it can be prevented by cleaning your canister filter regularly, but cleaning this kind of filter is not as easy as top filter or HOB filter. For hobbyists which have limited time, it can be a problem.
The key to choose aquarium canister filter among different brands is the amount of space provided for biological media. Also compare the features and innovative ways to deal with inherent problems s.a oxygen problem when power outage.
Internal power filters are submerged inside your tank. These fish tank filters tend to be smaller than HOB filters, meaning even smaller media chambers.
I think these fish filters are suitable for small tanks only (up to 30 gallons) or it can be used as mechanical filters to supplement canister filters, although their visibility within your tank can be disadvantage.
But, nowadays advanced aquarium technology makes internal power filters more powerful, some brands using external canister filter technology (multiple filtering) and making it suitable for bigger tanks (over 60 gallon).
These fish filters are also popular for low water habitats like turtle tanks, although top filters are better choice - from capacity & easy-cleaning viewpoint.
Internal box or corner filters are very simple filters, some plastic boxes are designed to be put at aquarium corner. It rely on air pumps to move water through the filter media - s.a sponge or filter-mat - in their chambers.
I think these inexpensive fish tank filters are only suitable for baby fishes' tank, the low flow rate ensures that the fry won't be sucked up.
Sponge filters are the simplest fish tank filters. Just connect the intake tube with an air pump using aeration-hose, the air flow will push water through the sponge. This fish tank filter provides good mechanical filtration (especially for eliminating small particles) and is excellent at biological filtration, with plenty of surface area that is easy for bacteria to colonize.
In small tanks that are stocked with small fish species like tetras, sponge filters may be the only fish filter you need. They are best for fry tanks (they won't suck up the baby fishes) or can be used in quarantine / medication tanks.
You should clean the sponge regularly to make the biological functions work. Just remember to rinse the sponge gently using it's own aquarium water to keep the bacteria alive. If you are using aeration, change your simple airstone with sponge filter for biological supplementation.
Undergravel filters are classical fish tank filters and popular in the early days. These fish filters consist of a filter-plate and uplift tubes which move water slowly through the plate. They are usually driven by air pumps with airstones. Sponge are usually put above the filter-plate as filter media, while aquarium gravel are put afterwards to keep the sponge down.
Actually, this fish tank filter is not suitable for planted tank, nutrients for water plants can't be kept in the plants' substrate. Besides, undergravel filters require regular gravel vacuuming to avoid waste to pile up. In time, these fish filters will loose efficiency and finally you have to pull them out for cleaning.
This fish tank filter is only suitable for plain tank with unheavily stocked. Avoid keeping goldfishes or other fishes that produce a lot of waste.
I found out that undergravel filters can be modified for keeping sinking-type of water turtles. Please read our Aquatic turtle supplies article for details.
Diatom filter is the best mechanical filter available. These fish tank filters provide crystal clear water, they can also improve aquarium's water conditions by removing algae, parasites, even harmful microbes. It can keep your fish healthier and promote faster healing for the sick ones.
What makes this fish filter so powerful ? The key is in the filter media called diatomaceous earth; a sediment made of the skeletons of diatoms, whose unusual pore structure can trap the smallest particles. That's why this fish tank filter can provide crystal clear water as previously mentioned.
Diatom filter is not cheap and can become clogged very quickly. This fish filter only suitable for short period usage, not continuously!. Use it if you are having problems with fish health or algae.
Fluidized bed filters are 100% biological filtration using fine grained sand as filter media. Most biological filters won't use sand since water flow can easily disrupts it, but these fish tank filters work by suspending sand in a column of water for increased surface area and contact time. It's useful for heavy bio-loads aquariums which need great surface area for bacterial bed.
Since fluidized bed filters remove oxygen from your system, you should add aeration for oxygen supply, especially in plain / fish-only tanks. Same as most external filters, these fish filters quickly build up nitrates when power failures. Some aquarists prefer them for planted aquarium, since they won't deplete CO2 that needed for aquarium plants' living and pH buffering.
They are also great for chemical filtration, known as fluidized bed reactors. Slow water flow increases contact time with the chemical media allowing highly efficient chemical filtration.
Wet Dry filter is the best biological filter you can find. There are 2 types of these fish tank filters : canister type and sump type, but they all have the same working principles.
Canister-type moves the water within the filter in bi-directional ways, allowing for extended contact time between bacteria colonies, oxygen and toxins to be decomposed. They are very easy to install - like common canister filter - with no need for drilling in the aquarium or complicated plumbing. The fish filter is perfectly sealed so there is no risk of water overflow while gas exchange is accomplished by breathing tube. The water output follows the dynamic input - as the filter fills and empties, creating wave inside the aquarium.
Sump-type works by trickling water slowly through mechanical media, building up a good amount of oxygen before passing through the biological filter. This fish tank filter uses external reservoir of water plumbed into your tank and it's more complicated than other fish filters. It is popular and widely used - with many variations- in saltwater or reef aquariums.
Sump-type is not suited for beginners, since it needs experience and extra efforts like good plumbing to make it works. But there are many benefits of a sump system, one of them is nitrate removal by applying algal filter within the sump.
Sometimes, some aquarium problems come from tap water. Persistent illness, algae or chemical poisoning are some problems that can come from your tap water. No other way, you should change the source of water for your aquarium or using water purification filters.
Chemical problems. If your tap water is high in heavy metals & impurities or if you need softer water for your specific aquarium's need, you can use :
- Reverse osmosis (RO) filter. These fish tank filters
remove contaminants and microscopic dissolved substances which can cause disease to your aquatic friends. These fish filters use filter media like sediment, carbon block pre-filter and membranes, it have the same working principle as drinking water's filter.
-
Deionizer (DI) unit. This fish filter uses deionization cartridge to eliminate harmful elements like heavy metals and toxins. This fish tank filter can be used alone or as an addition/combination to Reverse Osmosis (RO) filter. It will turn your tap water problem into healthy water for your tank.
- Ozonizers.
These fish tank filters use ozone (O3) to oxidize pollutants, harmful elements and other contaminants. It is extremely efficient, But too much ozone can harm your aquatic friends including aquarium plants.
Usually ozonizers are equipped with ORP (Oxidation Reduction Potential) monitor to control ozone levels.
Micro-organisms. Your tap water can contain bacteria, fungi, viruses, protozoans, parasites and algae. It can cause illnesses to your aquatic friends. You can use :
-
UV (Ultra Violet) sterilizers. These fish filters kill only free floating micro organism using high intensity ultraviolet light. It works by flowing aquarium water into UV tube where high UV light kills the microbes. It is safer than ozonizers and very easy to use. If persistent illness problems happened, you should use this fish filter after medications. It can't cure illnesses, but prevent it by purifying your tap water.
NOTE : Tank size refers to use as a primary filter.
|
Fish Filter Type
|
Tank Size (gallon)
|
Recommended Functions
|
Flow
|
Features
|
Concerns
|
| Aquarium External Filter (HOB) |
Fresh/Salt up to 50 |
Better use for mechanical filtration only |
Mid to High Flow |
Hang-on back |
Not enough space for 3 stage filtration, small surface area for biological media |
| Aquarium Canister Filter |
Fresh/Salt 30 - 400 |
3 stage filtration : Mechanical, biological & Chemical |
High Flow |
Larger capacities |
Inherent problem : Oxygen flow for biological media when power outage |
| Internal Power Filter |
Fresh up to 30 (some to 50) |
Small media chambers, use it for small tanks only or as suplementary mechanical filter for larger tanks |
Medium Flow |
Submersible |
Visibility within your tank |
| Box or Corner Filter |
Fresh/Salt up to 30 |
Mechanical with little Biological, best for fry tanks |
Low Flow |
Submersible, cheap, easy to maintain |
Frequent cleaning; small surface area for media |
| Sponge Filter |
Fresh/Salt up to 100 |
Biological & Mechanical, replace your simple airstone with sponge filter |
Low Flow |
Cheap, easy to maintain, fry-safe and quarantine-safe. Good secondary. |
Visibility within your tank |
| Undergravel Filter |
Fresh/Salt up to 200 |
Biological & Mechanical, not suitable for planted tank or reef tank |
Low Flow |
Cheap, Large surface area. |
Required regular gravel vacuuming, lose efficiency over time, extra effort for total cleaning when it clogs |
| Diatom Filter |
Fresh/Salt |
Mechanical |
Medium Flow |
The Best mechanical filter. It removes algae, bacteria and parasites. |
Expensive, clogs very quickly, not for continual use |
| Fluidized Bed Filter |
Fresh/Salt up to 900 |
Biological filtration for planted tanks & heavy bio-loads tanks.
Efficient chemical filtration known as reactors
|
Low Flow |
Great surface area for bacterial bed, won't deplete CO2 for aquarium plants & pH buffering |
Removes oxygen from water, need aeration for plain / fish-only tanks. Nitrate hazard during power outages. |
| Wet Dry Filter |
Fresh/Salt, customizable |
The Best biological filter, can be turned into 3 stage filtration |
Low or Medium Flow (varies) |
Use canister-type especially for beginners - very easy to install. |
May require plumbing and extra efforts for sump-type. |
There are many differences in opinion about applying fish tank filters combinations that could work well for your aquariums setup. Don't be confused ! If you already understood the basic principles of aquarium filtration, also the fish tank filters types and functions, you should be able to make a reasonable decision.
Here are some tips to choose aquarium filtration :
- Your aquatic environment preference.
It's fully depend on what kind of aquatic creatures you want to keep - fish, shrimp, water turtles, newts, frogs or others ? Also do you like your tank planted or plain ?.
Fish tank filters requirements for above choices are different. For example : Shrimps & crayfish are very sensitive to contaminants from tap water - you need water purification filters, Turtles tank needs strong filtration to keep it clean & free from odor, plain tank needs good biological filtration since it has no substrates within the aquarium and planted tank also had special requirements too.
All the differences actually serving one purpose : creating healthy aquatic life. You can read our complete advices for plain tank, planted tank / aquascape and turtle tank.
Please note that all biological filtration s.a Fluidized bed filters consume oxygen. Some aquarists concern about its usage in plain tank and only recommend it for planted tank. I think, you just have to add aeration to your plain tank to keep the oxygen level. While debates among aquarists in Oxygen, CO2 and water agitation issues in planted tank can be solved by using a protein skimmer or other Surface Cleaner - Just check out our Aquascape Supplies article for better understanding.
Wet Dry filter is the most powerful biological filter you can find. This fish tank filter is recommended to create good aquarium cycle. Although canister filters can be turned into 100% biological filters too.
- Your aquarium size & population.
If you have a small setup with low population, External Power filter (HOB) is quite enough especially one with a Bio-wheel or Wet/dry compartment. Sponge filter is cheap but very effective for mechanical and biological filtration for all aquarium sizes, you should add one or replace your simple airstone with it. Internal power filter and Canister filter are good for bigger setup with varies in capacity.
Please note that capacity of fish tank filter is limited by the space provided for biological filtration. You should choose the fish tank filters that have designs which maximizing surface area for better biological filtration.
How to measure effectiveness of biological filtration and sufficiency of biological media ? You should use water testing kits to closely monitor ammonia, nitrate and nitrite levels in your aquarium.
- Your budget.
Some fish filters like Diatom filters are not cheap. Although this fish filter will give you crystal clear water and prevent all kinds of illness and nuisance before they have a chance to affect your aquarium's inhabitants, its function can be replaced by using mechanical filtration with high-density filter cartridges or sponge filter.
|
|
|
|
FIT Store - AQUARIUMS & ACCESSORIES |
|
|
|
FIT Store - AQUATIC TURTLE SUPPLIES |
|
|
|
FIT Store - WATER PURIFICATION |
|
|
|
FIT Store - WATER TREATMENTS |
|
|
|
FIT Store - PROTEIN SKIMMERS |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|